Builders, Developers and Landowners: Residential Zoned Land Tax – What You Need to Know

Residential Zoned Land Tax – What You Need to Know

Residential Zoned Land Tax (“RZLT”) was introduced by way of the Finance Act 2021 and will be payable from 2024. The RZLT is an annual tax calculated at 3% of the market value of land which is suitable for residential development and is serviced. The aim of the RZLT is to mobilise lands on which housing can be developed in order to increase the much-needed housing supply by incentivising property developers to develop the land.

The first payments under RZLT will be due on or before 23 May 2024, and annually on 23 May thereafter. Payment will be made to the Revenue Commissioners who are responsible for the management of the tax. Given the time period between introduction of the tax and the first payment due date, any site upon which development has commenced before 1 February 2024 will be exempt from payment of RZLT.

Relevant Lands

In order to fall within the scope for the RZLT, the lands must, on 1 January 2022 (and 1 February after 2024), be;

  1. Suitable for residential development;
  2. Serviced, including public infrastructure for which there is sufficient capacity for housing to be developed;
  3. Included on the Local Authority’s map (see below), which will be updated annually; and
  4. Not included in the exclusions (listed below).

Exclusions

There are certain types of land which are excluded from the scope of RZLT as follows;

  1. Existing residential property including gardens/yards under 0.4047 hectares (1 acre). Where lands over 0.4047 hectares (1 acre) otherwise fall in-scope, owners must register for RZLT but are NOT liable to pay the tax;
  2. Land which is zoned for residential use but is permitted for use as a business to serve people in the locality;
  3. Land which is zoned for a mix of uses including residential where the land is integral to the operation of a business on or beside it;
  4. Derelict sites to which the Derelict Sites Levy applies;
  5. Land which is unsuitable for development for reason of contamination, presence of archaeological artifacts etc.

Local Authority Maps

The Local Authorities will issue maps on an annual basis which will indicate the lands within that Local Authority’s area which will be within scope for RZLT. This map will be published on the website of each of Local Authority every year. Draft maps will first be published in November 2022, supplemental maps in May 2023 and a final map in December 2023. Following the initial mapping process, maps will be updated annually and be available by 31 January each year.

Builders, developers and landowners will have a right of appeal as to their inclusion in the in-scope lands on the maps published.

Our Clients

We have identified particular scenarios in which builders, property developers and landowners including our own clients may find themselves following the introduction of the RZLT;

  1. Builders, developers and landowners intending to retain lands subject to RZLT

Valuations
If included as in scope for RZLT, a valuation of the lands must be carried out. RZLT is a self-assessed tax and therefore the owner/developer is responsible for valuing the lands accurately. A professional valuer may be engaged for such valuation but it is not a requirement. The property value must be ascertained for 1 February 2024 and can be used for the following three years. The valuation must then be revised every three years. 3% of the value will be the amount of tax payable. Documentation/records must be kept should Revenue seek to enquire further about the valuation provided.

Returns and Payment of Liability
Where lands fall in-scope of RZLT, the owner/developer of the relevant site is obliged to file returns and make payment. Returns and payment of RZLT will be due on 23 May annually for those landowners/developers who are in-scope on 1 February of that same year.

Penalties will apply to late payments and will be charged at 8% per annum. Surcharges for late filings may also apply at a rate of up to 30% of the liability for the year. In addition, undervaluing the lands can result in surcharges of up to 30% of the value of the lands. If sums remain unpaid, a charge will be placed over the lands by the Revenue Commissioners thus restricting a sale of the lands.

Where there is more than one owner of the site (e.g., the property is held jointly or in a property development partnership), only one return will be required per site which can be completed by the designated person. If there is no designated person, Revenue will appoint one.

  1. Builders, developers and landowners of lands subject to RZLT intending to sell or transfer ownership

Landowners or developers who wish to sell their land have certain obligations in respect of RZLT. These obligations also apply where ownership is transferring by way of gift, inheritance or long lease (35 years or more).

The landowner/developer, prior to the sale of the lands, must;

  • File a RZLT return;
  • Provide certain details of the site, the current landowner and purchaser;
  • Pay all outstanding tax and interest due. The seller must also pay or seek to make and agree with Revenue the amount of any penalties outstanding;
  • Submit all returns prior to completion of the sale;

Once these matters have been addressed, Revenue will confirm the tax position relative to the site at the date of the sale and will state whether there is a nil balance payable or if unpaid taxes are outstanding.

Outstanding liabilities will become a charge on the property if not properly dealt with, resulting in the inability to complete the sale.

  1. Builders, developers and landowners developing their property (Residential and Mixed-Use)

Where residential development commences on a site on which RZLT is payable, the payment of the tax may be deferred. In order to defer RZLT for the duration of the development; i) planning permission must be granted, ii) the site must be used wholly or partially for residential development and iii) a Commencement Notice must be lodged with the local authority. RZLT returns must continue to be filed throughout the period. A deferral will remain in place until a certificate of compliance on completion in respect of the development has been issued.

Where only a portion of a site which is liable for RZLT meets the criteria for deferral, RZLT remains payable on the other portion of the site. The site essentially becomes two relevant sites: one which meets the deferral requirements and one for which RZLT remains chargeable.

If the relevant site is zoned for a mix of uses, RZLT is only liable on the portion of the lands that are suitable for residential development. This will be deemed the ”qualifying part of the site” and must be valued for the purpose of RZLT.

  1. Out-of-Scope Landowners/Developers

Lands that are deemed out of scope as per the criteria set out above are subject to RZLT. However, for existing residential properties which are zoned residential on the local authority map and which comprise an area in excess of 0.4047 hectares (1 acre) in size, the landowner/developer must file a return in respect of RZLT and provide certain information in respect of the property.

If a property comes within scope, tax will be payable three years after it comes within scope.

If you would like any further information and legal in relation to residential or commercial property development then please contact Deirdre Farrell at deirdre@amoryssolicitors.com, telephone 01 213 5940 or your usual contact at Amorys.

Consequences Of Purchasing A Property Involving A Gift

Is Revenue Looking Your Gift Horse In The Mouth?

Important information for those receiving a gift towards the purchase of their property

If you’re lucky enough to be receiving a gift towards the purchase of your new home or property it is very important that you read the following from start to finish. It contains valuable information in relation to tax implications and other matters which may arise as a result of your windfall.

My parents are giving me €100,000 towards the purchase of my new home which is costing €500,000.  Am I not entitled to receive a straightforward gift from my own family to help us out?

If you are buying your property as sole owner and the gift is from parent to child, then, assuming you have received no prior gifts or inheritances from your parents, €100,000 falls well under the current tax-free threshold amount for gifts/inheritances between parents and children (otherwise known as capital acquisitions tax – CAT) and there will be no CAT payable by you. However, you are obliged to inform Revenue, as any gift to you during your parents’ lifetime will be deducted from your inheritance tax-free allowance on their death. There are exceptions to this however, for example when a certain amount of time has elapsed since the gift was made. Please see HERE for tax thresholds and other information in relation to CAT.

My spouse is purchasing this property jointly with me. Isn’t it up to me whether or not my spouse will benefit from the gift?

Unfortunately, there really is no such thing as a free lunch! As potential joint owners, your spouse will own 50% of the property you are purchasing. Consequently, in the case described above, your spouse would be considered to be receiving the benefit of 50% of the gift from your parents (i.e. €50,000).

Despite being their daughter or son-in-law, your spouse is considered to be a “stranger in blood” to your parents. This status falls under the Group C threshold – currently only €16,250.

Therefore, subject to the small gift exemption which may apply to the gift, your spouse will be liable for tax (currently at the rate of 33%) on the balance, i.e:

€50,000, less threshold of €16,250 = €33,750.

This figure equates to a whopping tax bill of €11,137.50 for your spouse which no doubt would be far better spent on your new home.

If, however, your spouse can prove that he or she contributed an equal amount to the gift out of their own money directly towards the purchase, then this could be used to offset your gift and the property can be owned on a 50/50 joint tenancy basis. Your spouse would however have to demonstrate this by corresponding banking transactions.

But we are a married couple – isn’t any gift between us tax-free?

In the normal course of events, a married couple can “gift” any amount of money or assets from one to another without any liability to tax. In this case, however, Revenue will view the gift as being a direct benefit from parent to daughter or son-in-law.  It is only after a period of three years following the gift that a spouse may benefit under a husband to wife scenario. This is called the rule against gift splitting.

Therefore, if the gift was given to you say two years ago and you were to wait a further year before purchasing a house together, in that case, there would be no tax liability for your spouse.

We want to buy our house now – is there anything we can do to avoid a large tax bill?

Yes.  You can opt to purchase your property as “tenants-in-common” (as opposed to a joint tenancy) in proportionate shares which take into account the percentage of the purchase price constituted by the gift. As tenants in common, this does however mean that, in theory, either party is entitled to dispose of their share of the property either by selling it or bequeathing it to a third party under their Will without your consent. This means that if you do acquire the property as tenants in common it would be extremely important for each of you to make a Will specifically stating how your share in the property should pass to the surviving owner on your death.

After the three year period has elapsed, as you are married, you will then be entitled to transfer the property into your joint names as joint tenants with no liability to capital acquisitions tax or capital gains tax, assuming you are both living together. Once registered as such in the Land Registry, on the death of either spouse the other will automatically inherit the deceased’s share with no tax consequences and sale of the property cannot take place without the other’s consent under any circumstances.

How is the tenancy in common calculated?

Using the figures referred to above, your spouse’s €50,000 share equates to 10% of the purchase price. Therefore, ownership of the property as tenants-in-common would be on a 45%/55% basis in favour of the spouse who received the gift.

Read more about this topic HERE.

We are co-habitants and may or may not marry in the future – what about us?

As co-habitants you are unfortunately currently still considered to be “strangers in blood” in the eyes of the Revenue. When purchasing your property, you can however avail of the “tenants-in-common” scenario described above.

I have received the gift from somebody other than a parent – what then?

This will undoubtedly result in significant tax liability for you as the direct beneficiary. Please refer to the Revenue’s website for further information. As regards your spouse, however, the situation as outlined above will remain the same.

Can we not just accept the gift as a “loan” and avoid all of this?

If you decide to treat it as a personal loan and repay the money to your parents/ benefactor over a period of time, then yes, it can be considered a loan. However, if you are availing of a mortgage to purchase your property, your lender will require evidence of how you received the money and how you intend paying it back without jeopardising your ability to discharge the monthly mortgage payments. Sometimes, a lender will require a commitment from you that the loan from your parents will not be paid back until after the mortgage loan has been repaid in full.

How do we go about transferring the property into joint names after the three year period is up?

This is a fairly simple and inexpensive matter which can be done by your solicitor. A deed will be drawn up, transferring the property between you both as joint tenants by way of “natural love and affection” and registering the document in the Land Registry. As you are spouses, there is no stamp duty and no registration fees are payable to the Land Registry. Furthermore, as set out above, there will be no capital gains tax on the transfer of the property provided you and your spouse are living together under the same roof at the time of the transfer.

My parents are selling their house to me/us at a reduced price – does this also constitute a gift?

Yes, it does and it is treated the same as if it were a cash advance. A valuation of the property must be carried out by a registered professional at the time of the sale stating the full market value at that date. You are entitled to obtain a number of valuations and select the lowest value applied to the property, assuming it is not inordinately low. The difference between the sale price and the valuation constitutes the gift amount. It should be also be noted that stamp duty is payable on the full market value.

So now that we have got over that bombshell, is there anything else we need to know about when receiving a gift towards purchasing our property?

Yes!  There is one further matter which relates to the title to your property which must be addressed.

If you are availing of a mortgage, your benefactor (the person or persons giving the gift) is obliged to sign a Deed of Confirmation. This document confirms that they will have absolutely no right over or interest in the property, either real or financial on foot of their gift to you. In other words, they cannot at some point in the future say “hey, wait a minute, I gave you €100,000 towards buying that house – I own one-fifth of it” (or something along those lines!).

As part of our undertaking to your lender, we must be able to give them comfort that when it comes to the title to your property, you and your spouse as mortgagors are the only persons entitled to ownership and, in the unlikely event that the lender were to re-possess the property there will be nothing (or nobody) impeding this.

A Deed of Confirmation is not the same as a gift letter (which will likely already have been signed by your parents). It will require attendance by your parent/s at the office of an independent solicitor who will witness the signing of the Deed and provide us with a letter confirming that independent legal advice was given. If the gift is coming from one parent only then their spouse will be required to sign a consent to the giving of the gift.

This will attract fees for you/your parents which will need to be borne in mind. You should advise your benefactor of this requirement and satisfy yourself that they are agreeable to do so before you sign contracts to purchase your property.

THE ABOVE IS A GUIDE ONLY – WE ARE NOT TAX ADVISORS.
Please note whilst every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the contents of the above article it is not to be construed as legal or taxation advice nor does it purport to be so. Specific tailored advice is required for every specific scenario. Amorys Solicitors is a boutique commercial and private client law firm in Sandyford, Dublin 18, Ireland.
For further information and advice in relation to “Consequences Of Purchasing A Property Involving A Gift”, please contact Wendy Scales, Legal Executive at Amorys Solicitors wendy@amoryssolicitors.com, telephone 01 213 5940 or your usual contact at Amorys.

Capital Gains Tax Loss Relief On Convertible Loan Notes

Capital Gains Tax (CGT) Loss Relief On Convertible Loan Notes

If your convertible loan note is capable of being characterised as ‘marketable’ and capable of commanding a ‘market price’ over and above the mere value of the loan, it may be possible to claim the debt as a loss for capital gains tax purposes.

Simple debt is not an allowable Loss for Capital Gains Tax Purposes

A loss made on a simple (usually undocumented) loan is not allowable as a gain or loss for capital gains tax purposes (see section 541 (1) (a) of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997). This is because a simple loan is not considered as capable of appreciating in value for capital gains tax purposes.

However, if the loan is characterised as a ‘debt on a security’ an allowable loss for capital gains tax purposes will be created (see section 541 (1) (b) of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997). The reason for the foregoing is because a ‘debt on a security’ is considered as a marketable asset, capable of appreciating in value.

What is a ‘debt on a security’?

Section 541 (1)(b) does not define ‘debt’ (and so it has its ordinary meaning) but defines ‘security’ as per section 585 of the TCA ’97 which includes loan stock.

Revenue have clarified in Guidelines on section 541 (par.13.3.) that the reference to loan stock should be regarded as meaning a general class of debt transferable by purchase and sale. The emphasis on ‘transferable’ is in line with the concept of a marketable capital asset capable of appreciating in value. As you will see below, this is the characteristic necessary to classify a convertible loan note as a ‘debt on a security’ pursuant to section 541 (1)(b) of the TCA ’97.

Is a convertible loan note automatically characterised as a ‘debt on a security’?

A convertible loan note is not automatically characterised as a ‘debt on a security’ for the purposes of section 541 (1)(b) of the Taxes Consolidation Act. They key test to apply is whether the loan note possessed the necessary characteristic of ‘marketability’ which would render the holder capable of selling same on the open market (see judgment delivered by Judge Francis Murphy in the Supreme Court case Inspector of Taxes v Keleghan [2001] IESC 43) and receiving an amount over and above the mere value of the loan (also known as making a ‘capital gain’ on a disposal of the asset) (see High Court judgment of Morris J in Mooney v McSweeney 1997 1 ILRM 42).

In the Irish High Court case of Mooney v McSweeney 1997 1 ILRM 429 the claimant was entitled to claim loss relief in respect of the convertible loan advanced in 1985 of £140,000. However in the Supreme Court case of Inspector of Taxes Taxes v Keleghan [2001] IESC 43, the claimant was not permitted to claim loss relief in respect of a convertible loan note which bore different characteristics to that in the first case mentioned – specifically there were restrictions on the right of conversion and no evidence was adduced to suggest that the holder could command a higher value than the funds deemed advanced originally.

It is common for shareholders of privately held companies, and their friends and family members to provide working capital finance to their company by way of a loan. In most cases the loan is provided on an informal basis with little or no supporting documentation. Where the debt cannot be repaid, the shareholder, friend or family member cannot claim capital gains tax loss relief.

Arising from the above we would advise that specific legal advice and assistance would be received before advancing funds to a company.

Whilst every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this article, it has been provided for information purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. Amorys Solicitors is a boutique commercial and private client law firm in Sandyford, Dublin 18, Ireland.
For further information and advice in relation to “Capital Gains Tax Loss Relief On Convertible Loan Notes”, please contact Deirdre Farrell, partner, Amorys Solicitors deirdre@amoryssolicitors.com, telephone 01 213 5940 or your usual contact at Amorys.

Farming Accidents In Ireland

Farming Accidents In Ireland

There are approximately 137,000 farms in Ireland with an average of 173,000 people employed in the agri-food sector. According to a 2018 Teagasc survey the average size of Irish farms is 43 hectares and employment in the sector accounts for 7.7% of total employment in the country. Farms are inherently busy and dangerous workplaces with the level of fatal accidents being far greater than in any other economic sector given the relatively small proportion of the farming workforce.

How do accidents occur on farms

The level of accidents on farms has been rising. In the ten years up to 2018 there was a 31% increase in farming accidents.  The Teagasc survey indicated that the majority of accidents occur on dairy farms, 42% of accidents involved livestock and 25% involved farm machinery and vehicles. Most fatal injuries on farms involving livestock are caused by cows and heifers followed by incidents involving bulls. Rolling vehicles are also a major cause of farming accidents with many fatal injuries resulting from being crushed, struck, pinned under or falling from a tractor or other type of farming vehicle. Trips and falls accounted for 13% of accidents with chainsaws and incidents in farm buildings accounting for 7% and 6% of farm accidents respectively. Falling objects and falls from a height are also the cause of many farm related accidents. The farmyard is the highest risk area where on average 64% of accidents occur,  19% of accidents occur in fields and 15% in farm buildings. The vast majority of accidents on a farm happen to the farmer or a family member with young children and elderly farmers being particularly at risk due to accidents on the farm.

The Law and Farms as places of work

The Health and Safety Authority (HAS) have published many useful guidelines and codes of practice on how to identify and mitigate the risk of injury in a farming environment. The vital message on farm safety is to ensure that everyone working on a farm is adequately trained, that vehicles and machinery are properly maintained and that safe work practices are put in place and properly enforced across the farm.

Legal duties of a farmer

There are a number of pieces of legislation that aim to protect the health and safety of those who work on farms. The Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 is the main piece of legislation that sets down the duties and obligations of farmers as employers.

Farmers have a general duty of care to their employees and are obliged to amongst other things:-

  • provide a safe place of work on the farm
  • ensure that safe work systems and procedures are in place
  • provide adequate training for workers
  • ensure that plant equipment and machinery is safe for use on the farm and properly maintained
  • provide personal protective equipment and clothing where necessary
  • provide adequate bathroom and washing facilities

Legal duties of farm employees

Farm employees also have a duty under the Act to amongst other things:-

  • co-operate with the employer so they can comply with the relevant legislation
  • use any personal protective clothing or equipment provided by their employer
  • not engage in any behaviour that would endanger their safety or the safety of anyone else working on the farm
  • attend training and undergo assessment where required

HSA powers

The HSA has the power under the 2005 Act to enter a farm as a place of work at ‘any reasonable time’  to ‘inquire into, search, examine and inspect’ that place of work. The powers of the HSA inspectors are extensive and they can serve an improvement notice on the farmer and also serve a Prohibition Notice requiring the immediate cessation of work where there is a breach of the Act which poses an imminent threat to health and safety. The HSA can also prosecute a farmer for non-compliance with the legislation. It is an offence under the Act to in any way obstruct an inspector in the course of their duties.

Farm Safety statements

Farmers are required as a matter of law to have a safety statement in writing that is made available to all farm employees and is also visible to everyone working on the farm. Farmers are required to identify the hazards present on the farm, assess the risk of injury associated with these hazards and identify and write out a plan to eliminate or control the hazards. The safety statement should be regularly updated as and when new machinery, vehicles or work practices are introduced. Farms with 3 employees or less are not required to prepare a safety statement however they are obliged to comply with the terms of the Agricultural Code of Practice.

Farmers need to be aware of their legal duty of care towards their employees. Legislation has evolved over time to give more protection to farm workers and they now have the same legal status as employees in any other sector of the economy. It is the responsibility of both farmers as employers and all those who work on farms to make themselves aware of the risks involved in any farm work they undertake and to do everything possible to reduce the number of accidents and potential personal injury claims on farms.

Whilst every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this article, it has been provided for information purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. Amorys Solicitors is a boutique commercial and private client law firm in Sandyford, Dublin 18, Ireland.
For further information and advice in relation to “Farming Accidents In Ireland”, please contact Daragh Burke, Amorys Solicitors daragh@amoryssolicitors.com, telephone 01 213 5940 or your usual contact at Amorys.

Gone Smishing? Credit Card Scams & Cybercrime

Credit Card Scams & Cybercrime

Bank of Ireland recently notified their customers of a smishing scam where some of their credit card customers had received a text message claiming to be from the bank. The text message told customers that their credit card had been automatically blocked for security reasons and asked them to click on a link for further information and to order a replacement credit card. The link brought customers to a phishing website where they were asked to input their security information including their account number, four-digit PIN number and their online banking PIN. Some of the bank’s customers unfortunately lost their money due to the fraudulent scam.

Cybercrime is becoming highly sophisticated and as consumers now conduct most of their banking online this is an area where fraudsters concentrate much of their focus. Banks regularly warn their customers to be vigilant against online financial fraud particularly when any text or email has a link which then requests the customer’s security information for their account. You should never give out this information even if the email or text looks entirely genuine. Any suspected phishing emails or smishing texts should be immediately reported to your bank and deleted from your device. The onus is placed very much on the consumer to be alert to suspected fraud which is understandably difficult for those who have no experience or knowledge as to how to identify potential scams.

It is vital that the terms and conditions under which your online banking are governed are carefully considered and analysed if you are unfortunate enough to be the victim of online financial fraud.   Legal advice should be sought to ascertain whether you have any claim against the bank to recoup your financial loss.

How to protect yourself against credit card scams and cybercrime:-

  • Make sure your anti-virus software is up to date on your laptop/computer.
  • There are anti-phishing toolbars included in most internet web browsers, make sure these are also the most up to date version.
  • Do not respond to any emails/texts requesting your personal, financial or security details.
  • Never open a link attached to an email/text that you are not sure about and do not enter your personal/security/financial information if requested in the linked website.
  • Avoid sending your personal/security/financial information in an email.
  • Before transferring money to an online account, ring the account holder to confirm their identity and the account number.
  • If you receive an unsolicited phone call from your bank, do not give your personal/security/financial information over the phone even if they have some basic information on you such as your name and address. Say that you will need to validate their identity and will contact your bank directly, do not use phone number given to you by the caller as this could be fake.
  • The Gardai advise that if you have transferred money to an unknown source as a result of a fraudulent email you should also report it to your local Garda station.
  • The default approach should always be caution. If you suspect anything fraudulent delete and report.

*Smishing – the fraudulent practice of sending text messages purporting to be from reputable companies in order to induce individuals to reveal personal information, such as passwords or credit card numbers.

*Phishing – the fraudulent practice of sending emails purporting to be from reputable companies in order to induce individuals to reveal personal information, such as passwords and credit card numbers.

Whilst every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this article, it has been provided for information purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. Amorys Solicitors is a boutique commercial and private client law firm in Sandyford, Dublin 18, Ireland.
For further information and advice in relation to “Gone Smishing? Credit Card Scams & Cybercrime”, please contact Daragh Burke, Amorys Solicitors daragh@amoryssolicitors.com, telephone 01 213 5940 or your usual contact at Amorys.

Pin It on Pinterest